SilentCritique.
Evidence-backed AI trust

Run a verdict
on your work.

We hold public AI to a hard, evidence-first standard. Point the same critique at your own product and get a clear score — strengths, risks, and the next move — in minutes.

Run your own verdictBrowse 10 real verdicts

10 public verdicts · every score backed by a reproducible test.

Live verdict

88

MCP server

MCP Time Reference Server

Narrow, deterministic utility

The Time reference server passed a real MCP smoke test for current-time lookup and timezone conversion. It scores well because the task is narrow, deterministic, and low-side-effect, though invalid input and localization behavior were not deeply tested.

See the evidence

How a verdict works

01

Run it

Point SilentCritique at your product, agent, or work. One run, no setup.

02

We test, not guess

Every claim is tied to real evidence — what was checked, what passed, what failed.

03

You get a verdict

A clear score with strengths, failure modes, and the one next move that matters.

Real verdicts, real evidence

These are live smoke tests we ran against public AI tools — not opinions. Open any one to see the exact checks behind the score.

Browse all 10

MCP server

82

MCP Git Reference Server

The Git reference server passed a real MCP smoke test: against a fresh repository it reported a clean status and returned an accurate commit log. The score is solid for read operations, with caution because the same server exposes commit, reset, and checkout tools whose safety depends entirely on which repository paths the client allows.

See the evidence

MCP server

81

MCP Everything Reference Server

The Everything reference server passed a real MCP smoke test: it discovered 13 tools and returned correct results for an echo and a numeric sum. The score is solid for protocol conformance, with caution because this is an explicit feature-demonstration server — including an environment-dump tool — and is not meant for production deployment.

See the evidence

MCP server

79

MCP Fetch Reference Server

The Fetch reference server passed a real MCP smoke test: it fetched a live URL and returned simplified markdown with length controls. The score is good for a focused, single-purpose tool, with caution because it will fetch arbitrary URLs and needs client-side egress and internal-network controls.

See the evidence

How we score

The rubric, evidence rules, and what a score does and does not mean.

For agent builders

Crawlable protocol, OpenAPI, and llms.txt so agents understand the contract.

Pricing

Free demo practice. $4.99 per instant critique. Every charge logged and visible.

Hold your own work to the standard.

Run an evidence-backed verdict in minutes. Start with a free demo or go straight to a critique.

Run your own verdictTry Demo Ritual
Run Instant CritiqueBrowse 10 verdicts